As the first of two(!) Snow White adaptations off the rank for this year, the comparison game is going to inevitably run strong. The problem is, so far, it's completely unwarranted. Whilst the Lord of the Rings-esque Snow White and the Huntsman looks to be a dead-serious fantasy epic, Mirror Mirror is a family comedy, that many people have been unfairly writing off as cheap and terrible, if for no other reason than the involvement of Julia Roberts.
But y'know what? Mirror Mirror is almost certainly the more fun of the two films, wearing it's family colours proudly on it's brightly-patterned sleeve. Granted, the trailers were fairly groan-inspiring, but don't let the marketing fool you: this isn't just throwaway kid's trash.
We all know the story: Evil Queen (Roberts) takes over kingdom. Step-daughter Snow White (Lily Collins, daughter of rocker Phil) is destined to be the fairest of them all. Queen tries to kill her. Snow hides in forest, meets dwarves. Bests Queen, marries Prince (Armie Hammer), lives happily ever after. No real surprises there.
What is surprising is that this retelling, helmed by Tarsem Singh (The Fall, Immortals), contains just the right mix of joy, humour and cleverness to actually make it fairly-fresh. The biggest thing that struck me about Mirror Mirror is that it feels closer to the children's fantasy films of the late eighties and early nineties, than a bloated CG-heavy kids film of today, which are usually packed with annoying pop culture references and "quirky" (read: irritating for the sake of it) characters. The emphasis is firmly on story and character, and the comedy is more natural and, as a result, timeless.
Of course, Roberts's Queen won't be for everyone, but that's really a question of whether you're a fan of the actress herself or not. I'm not, but I didn't find myself hating her as much as I thought, largely because her scenes are either with Hammer - a truly-game trooper when it comes to the role of the Prince - or Nathan Lane as her foppish lackey, both of whom act as perfect offsets to the Queen's oft-irritating dramatics. The real scene-stealers are the dwarves, played by largely-unknown short actors (although there's some familiar faces, such as In Bruges's Jordan Prentiss, Pirates of the Caribbean's Martin Klebba and Seinfeld's indomitable Danny Woodburn), who have an easy camaraderie and end up with most of the film's best humour - humour that is thankfully not at the expense of their stature.
The lavish production design and limited use of CGI help sell this as a more old-world-style fairy tale, and the few changes to the original story actually help to serve the film more, giving us some elements of surprise in a well-worn story. If there's any real complaint, it largely falls on the character of Snow White herself, flitting between helpless damsel and sword-wielding bandit, but finding no real balance between the two. This isn't the fault of Collins, who's genuinely lovely and fitting in the part, but rather of the script, which focuses on making every other character more interesting and entertaining.
This is a family film of the old style, and one that kids will love, but adults can feel a slight nostalgia watching as well, as it feels like the sort of film that Disney may have released twenty years ago. Those who want their Snow White action-packed and fantasy-heavy will get their wish in little over three months time, but for those who just want to bask in the nice simplicity and charm of the original tale, Mirror Mirror is a perfect alternative.
Rating: 3.5/5










